The Manhattan Club

New York City, New York

The Manhattan Club Reviews & Ratings

« Back to resort

4.3

out of 5
  • 5

    (60)

  • 4

    (27)

  • 3

    (8)

  • 2

    (3)

  • 1

    (4)

  • Resort location
  • Staff/Service
  • Cleanliness
  • Sleep comfort

Been to The Manhattan Club lately?

Add your review
  • By illonan
    Updated Jun 4, 2022

    The location is great! It's easy to walk to any theatre or 2 blocks to Central Park! Carnegie Hall is adjacent across the street. one...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 3 0
  • By alexk250
    Updated May 4, 2022

    For over 20 years my wife and I have enjoyed our getaways into Manhattan. With its terrific midtown location ,W56th and 7th Ave, Broadway...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 1 0
  • By stephenm386
    Jun 25, 2022

    Beautiful Resort in the heart of Manhattan. Easy walk to Carnegie Hall, Central Park and Broadway.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By allenn16
    Jun 15, 2022

    A short 10 minute walk to Times Square and Central Park

    Helpful? 0 0
  • By joanl263
    Jun 11, 2022

    In the heart of Manhattan.Across the street from Carnegie Hall. The perfect spot to see Manhattan and all its light. Near Broadway shows....

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By venuss4
    Apr 13, 2022

    Comfortable apartment layout ~ helpful staff Love the bedding…

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By patricial260
    Apr 10, 2022

    The Manhattan Club is a wonderful place to stay. The staff is always professional and helpful. My husband and I have had many wonderful...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By douglass251
    Apr 7, 2022

    The Manhattan Club's Penthouse Suites provide upscale, spacious accommodations in a great location in midtown Manhattan. We originally...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By margos15
    Mar 27, 2022

    Wonderful location in midtown. i can rent for 2-5 days Monday - Friday night. no weekends.

    Helpful? 0 0
  • By sandram592
    Mar 24, 2022

    We have been owners of the Manhattan Club for nearly 30 years, and been fortunate to enjoy all that NYC has to offer, including US Open...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By johannab10
    Feb 9, 2022

    Location! Location! Location! Our family has enjoyed 25 years of wonderful visits to NYC. We are original owners which means that our...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By tammyf187
    Jan 31, 2022

    I purchased a timeshare at The Manhattan Club as I was in Manhattan at least once a year for business and pleasure and loved the...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By marlene62
    Dec 19, 2021

    I have been an owner at The Manhattan Club (TMC) for about 20 years and have stayed there over New Year’s Eve, and during all seasons of...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By robertm1772
    Updated Feb 19, 2020

    I have been an owner at the Manhattan Club for 20 years and have decided to give up my so called "membership". This is nothing more than...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By johnd1920
    Aug 24, 2016

    For a rental in NYC, The Manhattan Club is the best deal for the money you can get (especially the penthouse units), close to the theatre...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By susank727
    Updated Jun 26, 2016

    Everything I could have dreamed of and more. In the heart of NYC...close to, well, everything! Central Park 2 blocks away...theatres,...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By bobl259
    Nov 15, 2012

    I have stayed here in the past and am going back again next week. We always enjoy staying at the Manhattan Club and when we use red week...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By paulag122
    Feb 4, 2012

    Great value for New York City. Spacious rooms RELATIVE to NY hotels. Fantastic location...near Times Square, Central Park, Carnegie Hall,...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By brandonw24
    Updated Jun 20, 2009

    This place has the ideal location for Manhattan, close to lots of entertainment, great restaurants, cultural attractions, and best of...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By seacliffranch
    Apr 4, 2009

    PENTHOUSE....This Club has location, location, location. Located in upper-midtown Manhattan it is an easy walk to Central Park, Carnegie...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By duffy104
    Feb 1, 2009

    We are happy to note that many of the 2007 complaints have been rectified! The rooms, although they vary in size from quite large to...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By mariae87
    Updated Jan 4, 2009

    We just purchased 3 nights, Dec. 30, 2008 - Jan. 2, 2009, for my parents 50th Wedding Anniversary through rentals at Redweek.com. The...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By lesleer
    Aug 13, 2008

    Nicely located hotel which was the main reason for the stay. Stayed in July on the 16th floor in a 1 BR with a view of the park. Nice...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By carol456
    Jul 12, 2008

    Great location and wonderful suite. Really loved it.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By stevens397
    Updated May 20, 2015

    Went for a few nights last month and my first stay in a renovated room. Big difference and I'm glad to see that the large increase in...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By philipaw
    Jan 26, 2008

    The penthouse suites are very luxurious and the size is very appealing compared to a typical hotel room in NYC. We comfortably fit 4...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By richardm372
    Dec 28, 2007

    I have been an owner since it's opening, When they became available I upgraded to the penthouse suite. Although there have been...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By robertm646
    Oct 4, 2007

    Best location in New York City!! The size of rooms is about average for the city, small compared to Orlando and other places I've stayed....

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By paul206
    Jun 2, 2007

    Just came back from an RCI trade into this resort. First the positive - location, location, location. That said, here are my negatives -...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By 14639
    Updated May 8, 2007

    Our family stayed in this Club for 6 nights in June 2004.This is an outstanding resort, close to all of New York amenities. It is by far...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By byrong4
    Apr 10, 2007

    I recently stayed for the first time. I am a new owner and had my worries because of previous reviews. Arnie and Tiffaney treated us like...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By tracy870
    Apr 9, 2007

    Great location, 3 blocks from central park, 5 from times square. Rented here in March 2007. Great rate for NYC, unit was smaller and not...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By di21
    Oct 18, 2006

    We travelled from Australia & have spent 7 days at this wonderful resort. It is situated in a very good location right near Broadway &...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By marlene109
    Oct 15, 2006

    LOVED this place. Around the corner from Carnegie Hall, 3 blocks from Central Park. Easy access to markets of any kind and the subway....

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By krischarnaw
    Sep 15, 2006

    We have recently came back from a 7 day visit at The Manhattan Club. Very nice location, close to everything, very friendly staff. The...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By kathy929
    Aug 15, 2006

    This is a great place to stay in NYC. It is near everything. Across from Carnegie Hall and not far from times square. Just a short walk....

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By onholiday
    Jul 30, 2006

    Stayed here twice now, Fourth of July week 2005 and Apr 06. Both times in 1 bed/2 bath units - rented from owners. These units are very...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By maggyaz
    Jul 11, 2006

    We so enjoyed our stay at the club; this is a fabulous location, a wonderful room with compact but convenient amenities, and great...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By stephen326
    Updated Apr 28, 2006

    Just came back from the Easter week vacation at this resort. Great location and service provided. The one bedroom unit is clean, nicely...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By helen73
    Apr 25, 2006

    Its interesting to note from reading the reviews that the service and accommodations have done "down hill" since the place opened! New...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By shannon221
    Apr 23, 2006

    The suites are great. Nicely laid out. Perfect location. Good service! Love it!!

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By rogerlay
    Updated Mar 14, 2006

    Be Aware!!! There are Mandatory Hospitality Fee that will be collected by the Manhattan Club at check-in. "Guests may pay by credit card...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By george971
    Mar 8, 2006

    On 12-07-05 I purchased a point program from this property. As of today they have not delivered on the points agreement and they are not...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By marilyn54
    Dec 15, 2005

    We have stayed here for the past three years the week after Thanksgiving. We have found the units to be clean and the service great. Have...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By nat4
    Updated Sep 7, 2005

    We exchanged into this resort and spent a week in September here. We stayed in a one bedroom/ two bath unit. It was REALLY small and...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By timregan
    Updated Jul 15, 2005

    Great place to stay. Right where you want to be near everything and oh, so comfortable when you return to it after a day of being crampt...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By w49
    Updated May 24, 2005

    One of the best purchases of any type that I ever made. Amazing midtown location helpful staff, nicely appointed rooms, no hassle...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By bobbin0308
    Mar 4, 2005

    Stayed in the Jr. Exec. Suite for 7 nights in Feb., 2005. GOT REALLY LUCKY AND FOUND THIS UNIT ON AN EXCHANGE THRU RCI (it can be done)!...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By pam304
    Sep 8, 2004

    To say we love this place is not giving it enough credit. The staff is excellent. We always feel like we are going to our second home. We...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By kathleenpeyer
    Aug 19, 2004

    Contrary to what one reviewer ( User: klraus) has stated, it is not "dishonest" to state that the full master suite (1 bedroom/2 baths)...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By yougogirl510
    Apr 21, 2004

    My friends and I were fortunate enough to be able to rent here for our spring break trip to new york city. It was great!! The...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By joolvera
    Updated Jan 27, 2004

    Great place to stay. Close to just about everything. Jr. Suites are a bit crowded for 4 people, but if all you do is sleep there, no...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By nancy_king
    Sep 1, 2003

    OUTSTANDING location and staff assistance. I wanted to purchase an apartment size (2 rooms, 2 baths) but got too many nasty opinions from...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By stever2
    Aug 3, 2003

    This was a wonderful place to stay. Our family of five had plenty of room, and the two bathrooms made traveling with kids ( 17, 23, & 26)...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By lyndenjgreenley
    Updated May 8, 2003

    Top quality in every respect. Spacious for Central NYC. We own a week & visit the Club annually. Superb location and amenities. This is...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By deejaygirl
    May 5, 2003

    Great location! Daily housekeeping -- the executive suite was a little small for 3 people but we didn't spend a lot of time in the unit...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By wivers9218
    Apr 15, 2003

    We own a floating week and we love to vacation in NYC and stay at the Manhattan Club. The resort and staff are top notch.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By fcburton
    Apr 13, 2003

    Quiet, elegant, staff is very responsive. The best location for everything. Walk everywhere. Feel very safe and right at home.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By pixie
    Mar 24, 2003

    We own here. It's top of the line.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By immagic
    Mar 3, 2003

    Units can easily sleep 6, additional cots are available, so the feedback about not sleeping 5/6 is not correct....staff does whatever you...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By klraus
    Feb 19, 2003

    These units have 1 bed and 1 sleep sofa. Listings stating sleep 5 or 6 are dishonest.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By christiand
    Feb 9, 2003

    I love the location in Manhattan.

    Helpful? 0 0
  • By gicjstanley
    Updated Nov 24, 2002

    Clearly THE premier time share resort. First class in all respects - locaton, facilities, amenities, furnishings.

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By rhackett41
    Nov 14, 2002

    If you want to visit the Big Apple this is the place to stay!. Across the street from Carneige Hall the location is incredible. the rooms...

    Read more »
    Helpful? 0 0