The Manhattan Club Reviews & Ratings

Please don't hesitate to rent my unit at the Manhattan Club. You will not be disappointed!

GREAT LOCATION! Within walking distance of the theatre district, and Central Park. Rooms are spacious and very well-kept, amenities include a comfortable lounge area.

Super Wonderful location 2 blocks from Central Park,steps to subway. Midtown, across the street from Carnegie Hall . Easy walk to broadway and other amenities. Grocery store two blocks away as well as liquor stores. Great access to Fifth Ave shopping. Lovely one king bedroom unit w 2 bathrooms,kitchenette,dining and living room areas, Best Place to stay ever!

Well located across from Carnegie Hall. Accommodating staff and well-appointed suites.

In the heart of Manhattan.Across the street from Carnegie Hall. The perfect spot to see Manhattan and all its light. Near Broadway shows. All the difference types of food and restaurants NYC is known for.A very spacious room forA Manhattan hotel . Your own private elevator to take you up to the Penthouse fl. Bar and lounge 26 th fl. Exercise room conference room all available to. When you come to Manhattan this is where you want to stay.

Comfortable apartment layout ~ helpful staff Love the bedding…

The Manhattan Club is a wonderful place to stay. The staff is always professional and helpful. My husband and I have had many wonderful stays. No matter what season you book, there is always so much to do!

The Manhattan Club's Penthouse Suites provide upscale, spacious accommodations in a great location in midtown Manhattan. We originally purchased a standard unit (in 2000), then upgraded to the Penthouse Suites when they became available in 2004.

We have been owners of the Manhattan Club for nearly 30 years, and been fortunate to enjoy all that NYC has to offer, including US Open Tennis tournaments and the Macy's parade!

Location! Location! Location! Our family has enjoyed 25 years of wonderful visits to NYC. We are original owners which means that our suite is large and luxurious.

I purchased a timeshare at The Manhattan Club as I was in Manhattan at least once a year for business and pleasure and loved the location! It is close to Central Park, Time Square, 5th Avenue and many other great destinations. It afforded me a large enough space to bring guests. The room was updated and always very clean. A small kitchen was great to have as well. Parking is half of what it costs to park elsewhere in the city while you are a guest at the hotel. The staff were always very courteous and would remember us from previous visits.

I have been an owner at the Manhattan Club for 20 years and have decided to give up my so called "membership". This is nothing more than a glorified hotel. The rooms are looking very dated and even a bit shabby. The televisions in the living are and bedroom are antiques with poor cable service. i would rather be sitting in my own living room with my 65" TV with streaming service. Also, this area of midtown has a lot of empty storefronts, littered streets and homeless people--a throwback to the 1980's. Most of the restaurants in this area that we frequented for many years have closed.

For a rental in NYC, The Manhattan Club is the best deal for the money you can get (especially the penthouse units), close to the theatre district & Central Park, very nice!!!!!!!!

Everything I could have dreamed of and more. In the heart of NYC...close to, well, everything! Central Park 2 blocks away...theatres, museums, great restaurants, shopping, public transportation, taxis...even valet parking. But, who needs a car?

Christmas in NYC! WOW!

I have stayed here in the past and am going back again next week. We always enjoy staying at the Manhattan Club and when we use red week the price is much, much less than any other hotel of similar quality. The location is terrific although I'd advise you not to park there since it's expensive...better to look for discount parking nearby and using either the bus, subway or taxi to get around. Or you can walk to many places as well. Consider brunch at Norma's (worth the price!) and be sure to shop around 57th Street and 5th Avenue. Enjoy!

Great value for New York City. Spacious rooms RELATIVE to NY hotels. Fantastic location...near Times Square, Central Park, Carnegie Hall, Fifth Avenue....

This place has the ideal location for Manhattan, close to lots of entertainment, great restaurants, cultural attractions, and best of all, Central Park which is a great place year-round to really getaway from the hustle and bustle of the City, but still 'people watch' and enjoy the outdoors, especially if you have kids or like to recreate with lots of open space. The Manhattan Club has many amenities, and beats any hotel room in terms of space, kitchenette facilities, and areas to relax with no extra charge. Most of the units are spacious, nicely furnished, and well serviced. The location is perfect for walking to many entertainment and dining options, and close to several public transit stops. We love visiting the City twice a year, and our family will not stay anywhere else now that we have discovered the Club.

PENTHOUSE....This Club has location, location, location. Located in upper-midtown Manhattan it is an easy walk to Central Park, Carnegie Hall and Times Square, Broadway shows, as well as museums, great shopping, dining and more.

The penthouse suites are beautiful. All of them have a free computer and internet in the room; two full bathrooms; two flat screen hi- definition T.V.s; a kitchen; doors that separate the two rooms allowing for maximum privacy if occupied by four people; access to the rooftop balcony and other amenities befitting a luxury penthouse in Manhattan.

Having a kitchen is wonderful on those days you would rather relax and have coffee and breakfast at home before heading out for the day or you can warm up that tasty doggie bag from the previous night. The Club provides bottom-less popcorn for movie nights in your room.

Daily maid service, a friendly staff, a knowledgeable concierge, pre-check- in and attention to detail complete the personal touch. Staying at the Manhattan Club is a truly luxurious experience.

We are happy to note that many of the 2007 complaints have been rectified! The rooms, although they vary in size from quite large to quite small are much more comfortable. The secret in getting the better room is to check in early! First come, first served. We have been in large and small units and it all depended upon timing.

We couldn't ask for a better place to lay our heads after a day and night in the City that Never Sleeps. We have had some really memorable times enjoying The Manhattan Club with family and friends!!

We just purchased 3 nights, Dec. 30, 2008 - Jan. 2, 2009, for my parents 50th Wedding Anniversary through rentals at Redweek.com. The purchase of the rental from the timeshare owner and confirmation of the reservations was a breeze! To our delight, my parents raved about TMC and how pretty and clean it was, especially the 2 bathrooms! They said the one bedroom suite was super-clean and luxurious. The 2 bathrooms were beautiful. The location was fantastic! They were able to walk downstairs and see the ball drop right from the corner of the hotel! The pictures prove everything they said. They said the check in was convenient and the room was ready by 3:30 pm. The porters, housekeeping and concierge staff was very friendly, while some at the front desk were not as friendly. All in all, they rated their stay a 4.50% on a scale of 1 - 5 and are definitely planning to go back and stay at TMC. I am seriously considering purchasing a timeshare for myself.